Ethan Finlay Justin Meram	7
	15	David Villa Andoni Iraola
Kei Kamara Justin Meram	49
Justin Meram Ethan Finlay Federico Higuaín	80
	87	David Villa

Columbus Crew	g	a	on	off	min	New York City FC	g	a	on	off	min
Wil Trapp	0		0	90	90	Tony Taylor	0		0	58	58
Mohammed Saeid	0		0	90	90	Steven Mendoza	0		0	80	80
Harrison Afful	0		0	79	79	Mikkel Diskerud	0		0	90	90
Michael Parkhurst	0		0	90	90	Andrea Pirlo	0		0	90	90
Tyson Wahl	0		0	90	90	Thomas McNamara	0		0	58	58
Waylon Francis	0		0	90	90	Frederic Brillant	0		0	90	90
Steve Clark	0		0	90	90	Jason Hernández	0		0	90	90
Federico Higuaín	0	1	0	86	86	Ronald Matarrita	0		0	90	90
Kei Kamara	1		0	90	90	Josh Saunders	0		0	90	90
Justin Meram	1	2	0	90	90	Andoni Iraola	0	1	0	90	90
Ethan Finlay	1	1	0	90	90	David Villa	2		0	90	90
Héctor Jiménez	0		79	90	11	Khiry Shelton	0		58	90	32
Amro Tarek	0		86	90	4	Kwadwo Poku	0		58	90	32
Rodrigo Saravia	0		90	90	0	Patrick Mullins	0		80	90	10

sources

• MLS MatchCenter (link)
• MLSSoccer.com (link)

series

Oct. 23, 2016	MLS	2016	Columbus Crew	1 - 4	New York City FC	Yankees Stadium	2
Aug. 13, 2016	MLS	2016	Columbus Crew	3 - 3	New York City FC	Crew Stadium	2
April 16, 2016	MLS	2016	Columbus Crew	3 - 2	New York City FC	Crew Stadium	2

scoreboard

MLS	2016	Chicago Fire	1 - 2	Montreal Impact	Toyota Park	2
MLS	2016	D.C. United	0 - 1	Toronto FC	RFK Stadium	2
MLS	2016	Colorado Rapids	2 - 1	New York Red Bulls	DSG Park	2
MLS	2016	Real Salt Lake	1 - 0	Vancouver Whitecaps	Rio Tinto Stadium	2
MLS	2016	Philadelphia Union	1 - 2	Seattle Sounders	CenturyLink Field	2
MLS	2016	Portland Timbers	3 - 1	San Jose Earthquakes	Providence Park	2