sources
series
| Aug. 30, 2009 | MLS | 2009 | Columbus Crew | 0 - 1 | New York Red Bulls | 1 | |
| June 27, 2009 | MLS | 2009 | Columbus Crew | 1 - 0 | New York Red Bulls | 1 |
scoreboard
| MLS | 2009 | Colorado Rapids | 1 - 0 | Houston Dynamo | 1 |
| Aug. 30, 2009 | MLS | 2009 | Columbus Crew | 0 - 1 | New York Red Bulls | 1 | |
| June 27, 2009 | MLS | 2009 | Columbus Crew | 1 - 0 | New York Red Bulls | 1 |
| MLS | 2009 | Colorado Rapids | 1 - 0 | Houston Dynamo | 1 |