Major League Soccer | Newcomer of the Year
| 2007 | Luciano Emílio |
| 2008 | Darren Huckerby |
| 2009 | Fredy Montero |
| 2010 | Álvaro Saborío |
| 2011 | Mauro Rosales |
| 2012 | Federico Higuaín |
| 2013 | Diego Váleri |
| 2014 | Pedro Morales |
| 2007 | Luciano Emílio |
| 2008 | Darren Huckerby |
| 2009 | Fredy Montero |
| 2010 | Álvaro Saborío |
| 2011 | Mauro Rosales |
| 2012 | Federico Higuaín |
| 2013 | Diego Váleri |
| 2014 | Pedro Morales |