| date | competition | season | round | team | score | team | venue | referee | att. | sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec. 8, 1889 | AFAC | 1889-1890 | 3 | Brooklyn Longfellows | 4 - 2 | New York Nonpareils | neutral | 2 | ||
| Dec. 8, 1889 | F | 1889-1890 | St. Louis Kensingtons | 0 - 0 | St. Louis Pastimes | 1 | ||||
| Dec. 8, 1889 | F | 1889-1890 | St. Louis Hibernians | 0 - 0 | St. Louis Shamrocks | 1 | ||||
| Dec. 8, 1889 | F | 1889-1890 | Brooklyn Longfellows | 4 - 2 | New York Nonpareils | neutral | 0 | |||
| Dec. 8, 1889 | F | 1889-1890 | Christian Brothers College | 0 - 0 | St. Louis Olympics | 1 |