| date | competition | season | team | score | team | venue | referee | att. | sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 23, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | Pawtucket Free Wanderers | 10 - 0 | South Providence Villas | Providence | 1 | ||
| Oct. 23, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | Olneyville Thorntons | 2 - 0 | Providence Association | Messer Street Park | 200 | 1 | |
| Oct. 23, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | New York Pilgrims | 1 - 8 | Paterson Almas | New York | 1 | ||
| Oct. 23, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | Newark Almas | 2 - 2 | Trentons Association | Trentons Association | 1 | ||
| Oct. 23, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | Fall River East Ends | 3 - 0 | Fall River North Ends | Fall River | 1000 | 1 |