| date | competition | season | team | score | team | venue | referee | att. | sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb. 23, 1890 | F | 1889-1890 | St. Louis Hibernians | T - T | St. Louis Hibernians 2nds | neutral | 0 | ||
| Nov. 14, 1886 | F | 1886-1887 | St. Louis Hibernians | W - L | St. Louis Hibernians 2nds | Union Park | 1 | ||
| Nov. 23, 1884 | F | 1884-1885 | St. Louis Hibernians | W - L | St. Louis Hibernians 2nds | 1 | |||
| March 16, 1884 | F | 1883-1884 | St. Louis Hibernians | 2 - 0 | St. Louis Hibernians 2nds | neutral | 1 |