- 4/10/1886 +
April 10, 1886 F 1885-1886 Ashton Association 3 - 0 Pawtucket Lorraines Cumberland 1
April 10, 1886 F 1885-1886 Pawtucket Free Wanderers 3 - 0 Providence Association Dexter Street Grounds 1
April 10, 1886 F 1885-1886 New York Riversides 1 - 1 Trentons Association Prospect Park 1