- 3/7/1886 +
March 7, 1886 F 1885-1886 Christian Brothers College L - W St. Louis AC 1
March 7, 1886 F 1885-1886 St. Louis Hibernians L - W St. Louis Shamrocks 1
March 7, 1886 F 1885-1886 St. Louis Thistles W - L St. Louis Thistles 2nds neutral 1