- 12/26/1885 +
Dec. 26, 1885 F 1885-1886 Ashton Association 0 - 1 Olneyville Thorntons Cumberland 1
Dec. 26, 1885 F 1885-1886 Fall River Conanicuts 0 - 1 Fall River Rovers North Ends Grounds 1
Dec. 26, 1885 F 1885-1886 Kearney Clarks ONT 2 - 1 Kearney Rangers 1
Dec. 26, 1885 F 1885-1886 Newark Almas 2 - 3 Trentons Association Trentons Association 1