- 11/3/1885 +
Nov. 3, 1885 F 1885-1886 Brooklyn Acteons 0 - 4 New York Riversides Prospect Park 1
Nov. 3, 1885 F 1885-1886 Brooklyn D.P. Fogartys 3 - 0 Williamsburgh Arcadians Prospect Park 1
Nov. 3, 1885 F 1885-1886 Anonymous Picked Team 0 - 6 New York Riversides Anonymous Picked Team 1