Andre Castel
| Sept. 30, 2012 | MLSr | 2012 | Columbus Crew Reserves | 3 - 3 | Philadelphia Union Reserves | Crew Stadium | 1 | |
| July 22, 2012 | MLSr | 2012 | Columbus Crew Reserves | 4 - 1 | D.C. United Reserves | Crew Training Facility | 1 |
| Sept. 30, 2012 | MLSr | 2012 | Columbus Crew Reserves | 3 - 3 | Philadelphia Union Reserves | Crew Stadium | 1 | |
| July 22, 2012 | MLSr | 2012 | Columbus Crew Reserves | 4 - 1 | D.C. United Reserves | Crew Training Facility | 1 |